Decibel Levels and the Effects of Sound on the Body
I would like to discuss the use of
sound in movies. Specifically the effects they have on the ears and body
between the extremes of the decibel levels: threshold of hearing to threshold
of pain. The three clips I would like to use are from Horton Hears a Who, Iron
man, and Bass Cannon (a music video by Flux Pavillion). These three clips have
extreme examples of audible levels found within the decibel scale, and use them
in different ways.
The first movie I chose was
Horton Hears a Who. This entire movie is
about microscopic people that live on a flower and communicate with the only
character who can hear their tiny voices, an elephant named Horton. Animals, in
our universe, are known to have more advanced hearing relative to humans.
According to a wildlife preservation site, elephants can communicate long
distances via low frequency sounds called infrasound (taken from
www.upali.ch/communication_en.html).
There is not much information on
the lowest possible decibel level an elephant can hear, but if you were to look
at a decibel (dB) level chart, the lowest recognizable noise for humans is at
about 10 dB, which is quiet whispering or leaves rustling in the wind. The
scale begins at zero, which is the lowest volume of a sound the human ear can
hear. Since animals’ hearing is more acute than humans, we can safely assume
they are capable of hearing noise at 0 dB.
For sound to travel great distances
it would need a lot of force behind it or, in other words, it would need to
begin at a high volume. Another way to
assist the distance sound travels is if certain wind speeds are at play while
the sound waves are traveling.
To sum everything up: elephants are
in fact capable of hearing infrasound which is noise that is inaudible to other
animals and humans, most other animals have more acute hearing relative to
humans, and to perpetuate sound over a great distance, it would need a lot of
force behind it. With all of this in mind, let’s look at the plot of the movie:
an elephant named Horton, who only differs from the other animals in his world
by the fact that he has massive ears, is able to hear extremely low dB levels
produced by the microscopic Whos’ in Whoville living on a flower that Horton
carries around. The primary character that Horton communicates with is the Mayor
of Whoville who does at times speak into a sort of megaphone tool when talking
with Horton, but will most of the time move around and speak at a normal
conversation level (about 60-65 dB).
Due to the size difference in these
two beings, the volume of sound produced by each would be dramatically
different. For instance, Horton’s voice would be far beyond the threshold of
pain for the Mayor, and, conversely, the Mayor’s voice would be too soft for
Horton to hear. Even if Horton did have super sensitive hearing and was able to
pick up the sound waves produced by the Mayor’s tiny vocal chords, he would not
be able to communicate with the animals in his world in the same manner. The
voices and noises of things in his world would seem to him to be a much more
intense volume that we would see him collapse in pain every time a character
spoke to him in the normal 60-65 dB level range. Being that this is a
children’s movie, this would have been most inappropriate. For sheer continuity
and aesthetic reasons, the director decided that the elephant’s massive ears
would be enough to catch the miniscule sound waves produced by the Mayor or
Whoville, without effecting the way his ears perceive natural noises in his own
world. From a cinematic stand point, these were wise decisions, they just do
not mix well with what is plausible in our universe and therefore stand out as
being a cinematic fiction.
The next movie I chose was Iron Man. This movie is about a man who
is an exceptionally brilliant scientist and engineer, Tony Stark. He creates
and builds weapons that are meant to be used by the United States Army. After
being kidnapped and he finding out that his company has been selling weapons to
the enemy forces as well, he creates a suit that allows him to fight the
terrorist forces and help the people he has put in danger. The whole feel of
the movie revolves around the fact that this man is far superior knowledge wise
to anyone in our universe, and can create amazing machines that are more
advanced than any technology we have yet to encounter.
At the climax of the movie, the
character Obadiah Stane, who was thought to be a mentor figure to Stark, turns
against him and reveals himself as the true villain of the movie. He “stuns”
Stark with high frequency device that he says was considered to be “too
inhumane” for the army to use. The result of the extremely high frequencies to
Stark’s bare ears temporarily paralyzes him. Other effects that can be seen
throughout Stark’s body are that blood appears to rush to his head, and he
appears to be in immense pain.
These effects appear to be
realistic to an extent, however, Stane then continues to speak to Stark and
unfold his villainous plan. Stark moves his eyeballs which signifies that he
does indeed hear what Stane is saying. Effects of this intense frequency would
result in hearing loss, and, perhaps if the technology is advanced enough, could potentially cause paralysis. The
key here is that afterwards, the victim would not be able to hear what the
attacker was saying to them. So while Stark appeared to be in pain and lost
control of his nervous system are plausible to our laws of physics, the idea
that he could still have the ability to hear is a little preposterous.
It is understandable why the
director would have made the choice to merely cause paralysis on Stark rather
than permanent hearing loss. This turning point in the movie was meant to be
the climax and lead up to the victorious triumph of Iron Man versus Stane. At
this particular point in the movie, he was meant to appear powerless. The
director achieved this by using the same kind of technology that caused the
conflict, action, and resolution of the movie. Had this device permanently
handicapped Stark, it would have been extremely dramatic, but also an extremely
disappointing ending as there would be nowhere to go from having a useless,
deaf superhero. So while this scene does fit in nicely to the rest of the
movie, it does not coincide with our real world laws of physics.
The last cinematic clip I chose was
the music video for
Bass Cannon by
Flux Pavilion. This music video can be found on youtube from this link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Htm_956k5ps.
It features two scientists preforming experiments on several different subjects.
The experiment appears to be testing the audible tolerance levels of the
subjects. The physical effect it has on the subjects bodies’ is what gives this
clip away as being cinematic fiction. When the tests begin, the sound coming
from the amplifiers appears to be so impressive, that it not only creates massive
sound waves, but also propels the air in front of the speakers which can be
seen in the movement of the hair and mouths of the subjects.
As the scientists increase the
intensity of the speaker volume, the effects in the bodies of the test subjects
include bloody noses, eyes rolling to the backs of their heads, appearance of
being in extreme pain, and large gusts of wind blowing past them. All of these
effects are meant to convey that the sound coming from the speakers is so
intense that it can manipulate the air resting in front of it and push it at
the test subjects. We visually see the effect of this when their hair and faces
are blown backwards.
At about 1:45 minutes in, the tests
pause momentarily and then begin again, but this time, the test subjects appear
as though they are being exposed to volume close to the threshold of hearing. This
is when their noses bleed, eyes roll to the back of their heads, and one even
begins to have body spasms. Along with these side effects, one could also
expect loss of hearing if the dB level was truly this loud. So these aspects
make the scene plausible to our laws of physics, but the volume pushing the air
at this great magnitude give it away as cinematic fiction.
The point of the video is to give
the audience the sense that the sound is truly impressive and visually, all
that is conveyed. The only piece that doesn’t work is the notion that sound
waves have the ability to move air particles at that speed and scale.
Looking at each of these scenarios
and how they were used give completely different impressions of the decibel
level from the threshold of hearing to the threshold of pain. They also give
false accounts of what is possible at these extreme levels for cinematic drama
and to make for more interesting footage. Through this investigation we’ve seen
cinematic use of highly acute hearing with
Horton
Hears a Who, extremely high and dangerous frequencies in
Iron Man, and the extreme of the dangers
of the threshold of pain with
Bass Cannon.
Looking at these uses of sound and their effects on the body give each scene
and cinematic clip a different feel while still maintaining their own aesthetic
specific to each one. I feel that each director was successful in selling their
perception of sound to the audience and it definitely did take a closer look to
see that there were errors in what they had portrayed.